Our Return Policy & Confidence Guarantee
Our Return Policy & Confidence Guarantee
We want every Records Geek order to arrive exactly as described. If something isn't right, this policy explains how returns and refunds work. Most items can be returned within 30 days of delivery.
Defective, Damaged, or Incorrect Items
If your item arrives defective, damaged in transit, or is not what you ordered:
- Contact us within 30 days of delivery at bill@recordsgeek.com with your order number and photos of the issue.
- We will issue a full refund of the item price once the return is received and inspected.
- The customer is responsible for return shipping costs.
- Original shipping charges are not refundable.
Change of Mind Returns (New & Sealed Items Only)
New items you no longer want may be returned within 30 days of delivery if they meet these conditions:
- Returned in original, unopened, factory-sealed condition with all packaging and accessories.
- Apparel must be unworn, unwashed, and have all original tags attached.
- The customer is responsible for return shipping costs, and original shipping charges are not refundable.
- A 20% restocking fee may apply to returns that were not authorized or that arrive in unacceptable condition.
Certified Pre-Owned Media
Every pre-owned disc and record is inspected, cleaned, and graded before it ships, and every pre-owned disc is guaranteed to play. A pre-owned item that does not play as described is treated as defective. Returns based only on cosmetic wear that matches the listed condition grade are not accepted. See our Vinyl Grading Standards for how we grade.
Opened Media
Because CDs, DVDs, Blu-rays, vinyl, and video games can be copied, opened media cannot be returned for change-of-mind reasons. Opened media that is defective is covered under "Defective, Damaged, or Incorrect Items" above.
Final Sale Items
The following items cannot be returned unless they arrive defective, damaged, or incorrect:
- Opened media (CDs, DVDs, Blu-rays, vinyl, and video games)
- Personalized or custom-made products
- Hygiene-related items
- Food and grocery items
- Gift cards
How to Start a Return
- Email bill@recordsgeek.com with your order number and the reason for your return. We will reply with a Return Authorization number (RA#) and return instructions.
- Write the RA# on the outside of the shipping box, not on the product packaging.
- Ship the return with a trackable service (USPS, UPS, or FedEx) and keep your receipt. Returns sent without an RA# may be refused.
Refunds
- Refunds are issued within 3–5 business days after we receive and inspect your return.
- Refunds go back to your original payment method. Your bank or card issuer may take additional time to post the credit.
- You will receive an email confirmation when your refund is issued.
Order Cancellations
Because most orders ship the same day, we can cancel an order only if it has not yet shipped. Email us as soon as possible with your order number. Orders that have already shipped follow the return process above.
Questions
Email bill@recordsgeek.com with your order number. We reply within 1–2 business days.
Last updated: November 17, 2026